|
43 | 43 | - **Open:** which particle phrases complete a given name, and whether that is a reading on the word or a list the rule kind holds (the particle-chain bullet above), #704 (decided 2026-11-03, below), and whether this rule reads O6's given-name list for it (`María del Carmen` against `João da Silva`), #959 (declined 2026-11-03, below); deriving `DEVIATES` from the rules (decisions/vocabulary-model's 2026-10-29 4f entry, item 6), which this rule leaves as it found it, having no surface in the name to declare, #754. |
44 | 44 | - 2026-10-30 #959 — THE WORD O6'S GIVEN-NAME LIST LEAVES IS THIS RULE'S. rules/O6 now leaves a listed given name where it stands (decisions/O6's entry of this date), so with both switches on the middle it leaves is this rule's to take where it is the unit beside the given name: `José Luis Pérez` reads given `José Luis`, family `Pérez`, where with the list empty O6 takes `Luis` first and the name keeps one given name. Where the given part holds two units before it, this rule takes the first and the listed word stays a middle (`Ana María Luis Pérez`: given `Ana María`, middle `Luis`), so a name of four words reads two and two only where O6 took its third (found by the #959 design-docs review). Nothing in this rule moved; its precedence clause states the reading with an example. Whether this rule reads the list itself is Open above. |
45 | 45 | - 2026-10-30 #753, phase 3g, decided in chat — NEITHER `es` NOR `pt` TURNS THIS SWITCH ON. ORCID cannot score it: its given box holds the middle names too, so the switch moves no record's agreement (0 fixed, 0 broken in every Spanish- and Portuguese-speaking country measured). PSC, whose form has a middle-name box, scores it against the filer's own split, and filers put the second given name in that box: under a `es` choice the switch alone takes Spanish filers from 31.8% to 15.7% (1 fixed, 980 broken), and beside `locales.ES`'s `two_family_names` from 82.0% to 54.7%; Portuguese filers fall from 61.1% to 28.5%. CLDR's `es` renderings read it right (the 2026-10-30 #704 entry, 6 → 8 of 8). The two sources disagree about a convention, not about a misreading, and the pack follows the boxes callers fill: a caller whose data writes the compound given name whole turns the switch on beside the pack. Recompute: decisions/O6's phase 3g recipe with `PolicyPatch(two_given_names=True)` added. |
46 | | -- 2026-11-03 #704, decided in chat — (Superseded in part by decisions/P10's 2026-11-04 #704 entry: the particle phrase is read by default, as a middle name, and this rule takes it as any middle unit; so the properties no longer move nothing with the switches off, `after_particle` reading by default and `shared`, like a patronymic, keeping a given name P10 would complete.) A PARTICLE PHRASE COMPLETES THE GIVEN NAME WHERE THE VOCABULARY MARKS ITS WORD, AND KAUR AND SINGH ARE NO GIVEN NAME. Settles the 2026-10-30 entry's Open. Two name-reading properties, each read by this rule and rules/O6 and by no other, so a parse with both switches off moves nowhere (the snapshot gains the rule examples' new texts and moves no reading; a grid of 128 texts under every order and switch pairing, token readings and `Reading.languages` included, moved no default-policy parse against master `a1b3e186`). |
| 46 | +- 2026-11-03 #704, decided in chat — (Superseded in part by decisions/P10's 2026-11-04 #704 entry: the particle phrase is read by default, as a middle name, and this rule takes it as any middle unit; so the properties no longer move nothing with the switches off, `after_particle` reading by default and `shared`, like a patronymic, keeping a given name P10 would complete. Its Portuguese clause, that no Portuguese-speaking word reaches the bar, is superseded by decisions/P10's 2026-11-06 #1118 entry: over the whole ORCID extract eight words do, and six more are marked for a Portuguese choice alone; and the unaccented `fatima`, which this entry did not weigh, passes on its Spanish counts.) A PARTICLE PHRASE COMPLETES THE GIVEN NAME WHERE THE VOCABULARY MARKS ITS WORD, AND KAUR AND SINGH ARE NO GIVEN NAME. Settles the 2026-10-30 entry's Open. Two name-reading properties, each read by this rule and rules/O6 and by no other, so a parse with both switches off moves nowhere (the snapshot gains the rule examples' new texts and moves no reading; a grid of 128 texts under every order and switch pairing, token readings and `Reading.languages` included, moved no default-policy parse against master `a1b3e186`). |
47 | 47 | - **The shape: a property on the word behind the particle.** The particle cannot carry it (`del` opens `del Carmen` and `del Río` alike), and the question is a vocabulary one (the 2026-10-30 entry's particle-chain bullet). Weighed: (A) a phrase reading (`text = "del carmen"`), most precise, telling Spanish `de la Luz` from Portuguese `da Luz`, but a third kind of phrase reading beside a birth marker and a given-addressing title; (C) a list the rule holds as a `Policy` field or `[rules]` key, vocabulary in `Policy` that no choice of languages or strict parser reaches; (D) O6's given-name list (`Lexicon.given_names`), no new data, but it would split `de la Cruz` (175 family boxes in ORCID against 38 given), `de León` (151 against 5) and `de la Rosa`, and is empty by default and has no Portuguese list. B was chosen: `after_particle = true` on a `given` reading, one word, compiled into the internal `PARTICLE_GIVEN_NAMES`. Its cost against A is a word whose phrase reads both ways by particle, which is left out (`luz`). |
48 | 48 | - **The reach.** Given-first, no family comma (a comma, and both family-first orders, already read `Silva, Maria do Carmo` given `Maria do Carmo` through the middle path), the given name one word with no middle between it and the chain, the chain opening with particles and then the marked word, and a name word left after them for the family, one with a letter that is no connective standing alone (a family of particles alone never reaches the path: assign leaves a trailing particle the family by itself, the phrase a middle, found by the second #1057 review), and no Turkic marker behind the phrase under that rule, as for the middle path (both found by the #1057 review: `María del Carmen y` and `Ali del Carmen oglu` had moved): `María del Carmen` alone keeps family `del Carmen`, as `Juan Carlos` keeps family `Carlos`. A given name of two words (`María-José del Carmen García`) keeps what it has, and a middle between leaves the chain to the family, this rule taking that middle instead (`Ana María del Carmen García` reads given `Ana María`). With rules/O6 on too, O6 leaves the phrase where it stands (decisions/O6, this date), so `María del Carmen de la Vega` reads given `María del Carmen` with both on, where the 2026-11-03 #959 entry in decisions/O6 recorded family `del Carmen de la Vega`; and the family the split leaves keeps its chained words as one unit, so `María del Carmen García López` gives no `surname2` (accepted in the rule). |
49 | 49 | - **The words** (es.toml; each records its counts): `carmen`, `ángeles` and `angeles`, `pilar`, `rosario`, `valle`, `caridad`, `socorro`, `mar`, `rocío` and `rocio`, `lourdes`, `mercedes`, `maría` and `maria`, `milagro`, `milagros`, `cisne`, `fátima`, `concepción`, `nieves`, `consuelo`, `jesús` — 23. Measured 2026-11-03 on ORCID's `raw.jsonl` of the 2026-10-27 fetch (20,000 records a country at most): for each word, the records whose given box ends with a particle run (`Lexicon.default()`'s particles, NFC lower case) and the word, against those whose family box opens with a particle run and the word and holds more words after them, the shape that competes; kept where the given side is at least 90% with ten given records or more, counted over Spain and Spanish-speaking America (ES MX AR CO CL PE VE EC UY BO PY CR GT CU DO HN SV NI PA PR AD) and, separately, Portugal, Brazil and Portuguese-speaking Africa (BR PT AO MZ CV GW ST TL). `carmen` 1,261 to 5, `valle` 235 to 26 (exactly 90.0%), `rosario` 260 to 27. Left out: no Portuguese-speaking word reaches the bar (`carmo` 21 to 6, `rosário` 21 to 8, `conceição` 25 to 25, `fátima` 32 to 4, which the Spanish counts carry, 27 to 1); unaccented `jesus`, 203 to 16 in Spanish-speaking countries but 67 to 41 in Portuguese-speaking ones; `luz` (12 to 6, and Portuguese `da Luz` 4 to 5), `dios`, `paz`, `cruz`; and two that pass by count but are no compound given name, `c.` (an initial) and `piero` (Italian `del Piero`, 10 to 0). The Catalan phrases (`dels Àngels`, `de les Neus`, `de la Mercè`) barely occur, so no Catalan word is marked. The PSC register agrees where it can, its filers putting `del Carmen` in the middle-name box 21 times and the surname box 2, `del Mar` 11 and 0, `del Pilar` 10 and 1. `dels` stays out of `ca.toml` (the reason void since decisions/P10's 2026-11-04 entry, which holds the question Open): the property moves nothing with the switch off, so a `dels` particle would still move `Maria dels Àngels Puig` from middle `dels Àngels` to family `dels Àngels Puig` by default (the #704 comment of 2026-10-31). |
|
0 commit comments